Newcastle 2 - Manchester City 2 (Premier League, October 20, 2008) In the thirteenth minute, Habib Beye (did he touch the ball?) was shown the red card for a foul on Robinho who was inside the box and through on goal, the Brazilian stepped up to take the resulting penalty to put City one-up. But Newcastle showed real resilience to hit back just before the break with Shola Ameobi